Intressanta aspekter om hur man skapar talflyt- (An experiment)

Alex, your experience is really very interesting. It shows that stuttering is not a problem of control. Like you, when I am alone and try to control my speech, I don’t stutter. If I purposely scan each word I am going to utter, I don’t stutter. Control is not the cause of my stuttering, it’s a response to stuttering or to the fear of stuttering. It’s just a way to escape from stuttering but stuttering appears before.

I share Anna’s point. My thoughts are the triggers for stuttering. And this trigger makes me switch in stuttering mode, in tension mode but not in control mode. Control is not the problem. If I a am alone and try to stutter, the only way for me to produce my stuttering is to add tension in my throat, in my chest or in my tongue. So my problem is tension and I like Anna’s idea to replace tension by relaxation. And this tension, As John says, is a mean to hold back, to prevent my words to get out. This tension is the result of the struggle of two forces : one flow trying to get outside and a pression trying to shut the pipe.
2017-09-29 20:26 GMT+02:00 [neurosemanticsofstuttering] <>:

I did an experiment to see if speaking in an overly controlled way is the main cause of speech blocks. I pretty much never have any speech blocks when I’m talking out loud in a room by myself, so my experiment was to see if I would block in a room by myself if I purposely control the mechanics of speaking. I tried preplanning my sentences and visualizing the words before I said them, I tried controlling my articulation, I tried monitoring my speech, I tried thinking about every word I said and every breath I took, and guess what happened? I still never even had one speech block. The only way I could create blocks in a room by myself is by purposely tensing up my throat. Now I’m convinced that controlling the mechanics of speech isn’t actually the main cause of stuttering.

I think the main cause of stuttering is one of two things: our anticipatory anxiety about speaking in certain situations causes our vocal cords to get so tense that they can’t vibrate, or as our guru John Harrison says, our subconscious desire to hold back causes us to tense up our vocal cords to prevent ourselves from speaking. I’m not sure which one of those explanations it is though. I still think controlling the mechanics of speech is counterproductive because if we preplan a sentence we might start worrying about saying certain words which increases our anticipatory anxiety.

I think whichever explanation is right, the solution is the same. I think if we stop constantly thinking about speech, stop trying to control speech, stop thinking of stuttering as a terrible thing to be avoided at all costs, stop worrying about what people will think of us if we stutter, stop being overly perfectionistic, stop overthinking everything we do and just live in the moment, stop thinking of life as a performance or competition and instead just think of life as a fun adventure, and stop acting like a shy unassertive person, then that will provide a difficult environment for speech blocks to happen in, and they will happen less and less over time until eventually we think to ourselves ”I can’t even remember the last time I had a speech block!”

I started thinking like that yesterday, and immediately my fluency dramatically increased. I was actually way more fluent than I was after 9 months of obsesively trying to use Dr. Shwartz’s slow start technique perfectly. I was shocked! But I won’t think about it too much because then I’ll be back to judging speech and thinking of speaking as a performance.


Un peu d’aide et d’optimisme pour les adultes et parents d’enfants qui bégaient

Posted by: Laurent Goodbyebeg <>

Jag tycker att ovanstående är så bra, att jag har kopierat allt från Laurants svar till Alex och saiten  [neurosemanticsofstuttering]. Här finns enligt min mening ytterst tänkvärda konstateranden som rör talflyt. Och hur man åstadkommer detta.  ”I can’t even remember the last time I had a speech block!” Det här är lärorik information om hur man kan åstadkomma flytande tal.

Jag gillar ju svenska informativa golfspelsinstruktioner. Se t. ex. tidningen SVENSK GOLF. Man kan överföra golfspelsträningsinstruktioner till motsvarande talträningsinstruktioner. Då kan man även lära sig att överföra nödvändiga och framgångsrika golfspelsdetaljer till helt avgörande motsvarande talträningsdetaljer FRAMGÅNGSRIKT om man tränar lika omsorgsfullt i båda sammanhangen. Häpnadsväckande! Prövat och erfarit.


Vänligen logga in med någon av dessa metoder för att lägga till din kommentar: Logo

Du kommenterar med ditt Logga ut /  Ändra )


Du kommenterar med ditt Google+-konto. Logga ut /  Ändra )


Du kommenterar med ditt Twitter-konto. Logga ut /  Ändra )


Du kommenterar med ditt Facebook-konto. Logga ut /  Ändra )


Ansluter till %s

%d bloggare gillar detta: